Summary
Self-funding can give mid-sized companies greater control over plan design, increased claims transparency, and opportunities to manage healthcare costs over time. Learn how self-funding works, when to consider it, and how to prepare for the transition.
Self-funding health benefits used to be a conversation reserved for much larger employers. That’s changing as rising healthcare costs push companies to reconsider how they finance their medical plans earlier in their growth. 
The move toward self-funding has been especially pronounced for mid-sized companies. According to recent Sequoia data, the share of companies with 501 to 999 employees that are self-funded increased from 26% in 2024 to 43% in 2026.
There’s a lot to consider with self-funding. While it can open the door to a plan designed around your workforce, it also brings financial variability and a more active role for the employer. 
Self-funding isn’t a decision you can make at renewal. If you’re targeting it for an upcoming plan year, the evaluation needs to start well before your renewal cycle. Give yourself time to understand the financial implications, align internal teams, and prepare for year-round plan management.
To help you understand what the move involves, here are the questions I hear most often from mid-sized companies about self-funding.
What does self-funding mean?
In the simplest terms, self-funding means the employer pays eligible healthcare claims instead of paying an insurance carrier to take on that risk through a fixed premium.
The employer doesn’t decide whether each claim is eligible. Instead, a third-party administrator (TPA) reviews the claim against the plan terms and facilitates payment using employer-funded plan assets. The employer also buys stop-loss insurance for financial protection against high claims.
Pharmacy benefits are another part of the structure. A pharmacy benefit manager (PBM) administers that portion of the plan. When an employer carves out pharmacy benefits, it contracts with a separate PBM instead of using the medical carrier’s pharmacy arrangement. That arrangement can give the employer more control over those dollars.
Why are more mid-sized companies considering self-funding?
There are several reasons for this. First, more TPAs and stop-loss carriers have become willing to work with smaller groups than they were several years ago.
Also, many mid-sized companies are competing with much larger organizations for talent. They want to offer benefits that can rival those of larger companies, but fully insured plans may offer less flexibility to customize coverage. Self-funding gives employers greater flexibility to define coverage and restrictions in the plan document, subject to applicable legal and regulatory requirements. GLP-1 medications, fertility benefits, and family planning services are common examples of benefits that are often tailored to a company’s workforce through self-funding.
Finally, data improves as enrollment grows. A company with around 100 covered employees may begin to see useful patterns in their healthcare data. With around 200 covered employees, it may have enough information to evaluate how the plan is performing and whether changes are needed.
What are the main advantages of self-funding health benefits?
The first advantage is control. An employer can create a health plan that fits its workforce and its current stage of growth. That may mean expanding a benefit, setting different coverage rules, or bringing in a focused provider for a specific area of care.
The second is transparency. Under a fully insured plan, the employer pays the carrier’s premium and receives limited visibility into how those dollars are spent. A self-funded employer can see how members are using the plan, where claims are concentrated, and what may be driving costs.
That information gives the employer a basis for future plan decisions. The value develops over time as the company learns from its own claims experience and adjusts the plan.
Will self-funding save money right away?
Maybe. Self-funding is sometimes presented as the answer to a high renewal, but first-year savings are not guaranteed. If they occur, they may reflect favorable underwriting or a healthy population. 
Savings are most likely to emerge in the second or third year, or later. Once an employer can see how people are using the plan, it can develop programs aimed at better outcomes and lower costs.
For example, an employer may begin with broad GLP-1 coverage for weight loss, then learn that pharmacy spending has increased sharply. The next year, it could pair access with a behavior-management program that supports appropriate use and broader health goals. If musculoskeletal claims are a large cost driver, the employer could consider a focused provider or a network of physicians with lower costs and better outcomes.
Those decisions take data, time, and follow-through. Any first-year savings should be viewed as a potential benefit, rather than the primary reason to make the move.
What signs suggest a company should consider self-funding?
Repeated renewal increases deserve attention, especially when the claims data doesn’t appear to support the carrier’s proposed increase. If a company has a good loss ratio and still receives increases year after year, it may want to explore whether keeping more of those dollars would make sense.
Consider a company with a 90% loss ratio, meaning the carrier pays 90 cents in claims for every dollar it collects in premium. If that company still receives an increase, its leaders may question whether the carrier’s renewal assumptions fully explain the increase. 
The desire to build a more attractive plan can be another signal. So can frustration with waiting for a late-summer renewal and then making benefits decisions under a tight deadline.
The company’s claims, enrollment, and financial data still have to support the discussion, and leaders must be comfortable with cost variability because self-funding doesn’t provide the fixed monthly premium of a fully insured plan. For some employers, that predictability remains a good reason to stay fully insured.
What new responsibilities does the employer take on?
A self-funded plan requires active management throughout the year. Finance becomes more involved in monthly claims reporting and spending reviews. HR takes on new responsibilities during setup and ongoing administration. And the executive team needs to understand what the plan is intended to accomplish and what it may cost.
The employer may also have to make decisions it didn’t face under a fully insured plan. If a TPA denies a claim based on the plan document and the employee appeals, the employer, as plan sponsor, may have a decision to make.
A TPA can carry much of the administrative workload, and mid-sized companies rarely need to add headcount solely because they self-fund. A dedicated benefits leader can help, but a larger in-house benefits team is more common among employers with 5,000 or 10,000 employees.
When should planning for a move to self-funding begin?
For a January 1 effective date, planning should begin well before renewal arrives. Start the internal education and decision process in late winter or early spring. That gives leaders time to agree on why the company is considering self-funding, what it wants from the plan, and how much variability it can accept.
By late summer, the company and its consultant should be refining claims projections, aligning expectations with finance, defining the plan’s coverage, identifying fiduciary responsibilities, and working through stop-loss options. In the final two to four months, teams may meet weekly or every other week with the TPA and PBM while they finalize contracts, plan terms, stop-loss coverage, reporting, and internal roles.
A self-funded plan can be set up in two to three months, but that pace can make the experience rushed. Waiting for the fully insured renewal before beginning the conversation leaves less time to build executive support and make thoughtful plan decisions.
What should companies do if the current year’s window is too tight?
Use the time before the next renewal to prepare. Begin with the reason for considering self-funding. If the only goal is a lower first-year cost, the company may be disappointed. If the goals are more control, greater transparency, and a plan designed for the workforce, leaders have a stronger basis for evaluating the move. 
Here are key steps:
- Build understanding and support from the CEO through the HR team.
- Review available claims and loss-ratio data with the consultant.
- Define the coverage the company wants and the restrictions it will accept.
- Prepare finance for monthly reporting and claims-spend reviews.
- Clarify the responsibilities of HR, finance, executives, designated plan fiduciaries, the TPA, and the PBM.
- Evaluate stop-loss coverage and the amount of cost variability the company can manage.
That preparation gives the company time to make the decision on its own terms. It also changes the renewal conversation. Instead of waiting to learn whether the carrier will deliver a 2% increase or a 42% increase, the employer can review what it spent, project what it may spend next, and decide whether the plan needs to change.
How should a company think about the decision?
Self-funding offers more freedom to shape the plan, and that freedom comes with more responsibility. The employer gains control over plan design and a closer view of claims spending. In return, its leaders must stay engaged throughout the year and be prepared for volatility.
A good consultant should help the company evaluate the numbers, prepare each internal team, and manage the process. If this year’s window is too narrow, use the coming plan year to prepare for the next one. The goal is to decide with enough time, information, and internal support to do it well. 
Find the Right Funding Structure for Your Company
Every company has different benefits goals, financial considerations, and comfort with cost variability. Sequoia advisors can help you evaluate your options and determine which funding structure best supports your people and your business. Connect with our team to get started.
Last Updated:




